Truck lease vs. buy calculator
Enter your loan terms and lease quote. The calculator shows the total cost of each option over the same period and finds the break-even month — when buying becomes cheaper than continuing to lease.
Your results
Estimate only, not financial, tax or legal advice. Check your own figures and contracts before relying on it.
How the comparison works
The calculator compares both options over the same analysis period — the shorter of your loan term and lease term — so neither option has an unfair time advantage.
- Buy monthly payment uses the standard amortization formula with your loan amount, APR, and term.
- Cumulative buy cost at month M = down payment + (monthly payment × M) − equity at M. Equity is estimated as (residual value × M ÷ loan term), a linear approximation. Actual equity depends on amortization pace and the truck's market value.
- Cumulative lease cost at month M = lease payment × M (no equity component).
- Break-even month = the first month when cumulative buy net cost drops below cumulative lease cost. Before this point, leasing has cost you less in total.
Worked example
You're comparing a $120,000 truck purchase ($20,000 down, 8% APR, 60 months, $30,000 estimated resale) against a $1,800/month TRAC lease (48 months).
- Loan amount: $100,000
- Buy monthly payment: ~$2,028
- Analysis period: 48 months (shorter of 60 and 48)
- Cumulative buy over 48 months: $20,000 + ($2,028 × 48) − equity ≈ $77,344 − $24,000 equity = $53,344 net
- Cumulative lease over 48 months: $1,800 × 48 = $86,400
- Net advantage of buying: ~$33,000 over the 48-month window
In this example buying is cheaper because the lease payment ($1,800) is nearly equal to the loan payment (~$2,028) while the buyer builds $24,000 in equity. The break-even comes early because the down payment is quickly offset by equity growth relative to lease cost.
What this calculator does not cover
- Mileage overages. TRAC leases have annual mileage caps (typically 120,000–150,000 miles); overage fees of $0.05–$0.15/mile can add thousands to the lease total. Add estimated overages to your lease cost before comparing.
- Tax differences. Lease payments are fully deductible; loan interest plus Section 179/bonus depreciation may be more valuable in the purchase year. A tax professional can show your specific after-tax cost.
- Maintenance. Full-service leases include maintenance; finance leases and loan purchases do not. Add your expected maintenance costs to the buy side for a full comparison.
- Insurance. Comparable under both options; excluded from this calculator.
Once you have monthly payment figures, use the cost per mile calculator to see how the payment affects your per-mile cost, and the load profit calculator to see whether your loads cover it.
What TRAC leases actually cost each month
TRAC lease payments are built from the truck's capitalized cost, the projected residual, and an implicit money factor that usually works out to 7–11% APR depending on your credit and the leasing company's appetite. Because the residual is subtracted before the payment is computed, a lease on a truck that holds value well can come in below a comparable loan payment even though the lease rate is higher. The ranges below reflect quotes typical of 2024–2025 commercial truck leasing programs for owner-operators with reasonable credit (640+); weak credit pushes payments up or requires a larger security deposit.
| Truck | Typical term | Monthly payment | Annual mileage cap |
|---|---|---|---|
| New Class 8 sleeper ($150k–$180k) | 48–60 months | $2,300–$3,100 | 120,000–150,000 |
| New day cab ($110k–$130k) | 36–48 months | $1,900–$2,500 | 100,000–125,000 |
| 3–5 year old used sleeper ($70k–$90k) | 36–48 months | $1,500–$2,100 | 100,000 |
| Older work truck ($40k–$55k) | 24–36 months | $1,100–$1,600 | 75,000–100,000 |
Read the mileage cap before signing: overage penalties run $0.05–$0.15 per mile, and a driver who runs 140,000 miles on a 100,000-mile cap owes $2,000–$6,000 at turn-in. OTR operators should negotiate the cap up front or buy the overage allowance into the lease.
Total cost of ownership: line items the monthly payment hides
The payment comparison is only part of the story. Ownership and leasing carry different hidden costs, and which side wins depends on your mileage, maintenance habits, and tax situation. Ownership wins on equity and unlimited miles but exposes you to repair risk on an aging truck; leasing caps your commitment and often bundles maintenance, but charges for the option and penalizes excess miles. The table below lines up the line items that never appear in an advertised monthly payment.
| Line item | Buy with a loan | TRAC lease |
|---|---|---|
| Equity build | $4,000–$6,000/year early in the loan | None (residual buyout optional) |
| Maintenance responsibility | Yours — $0.12–$0.20/mile, rising with age | Often included or capped in full-service leases |
| Mileage limits | None | 120,000–150,000/year, $0.05–$0.15/mile over |
| Tax deduction | Interest + depreciation (Section 179/bonus in year 1) | Entire payment deductible |
| End-of-term exposure | Resale risk (you keep the upside and the downside) | TRAC true-up: owe if it sells below residual |
| Downtime risk | Repair bills come out of your pocket | Lessor covers repairs under full-service terms |
| Credit requirement | Typically 620+ FICO for standard lenders | Often 640+; easier approval than loans |
The honest decision framework: if you run high, predictable miles and intend to keep the truck past the loan, buying wins on total cost — the worked example above is typical. If your freight is seasonal, your revenue is unproven, or you want maintenance risk off your books for the first two years, a lease buys flexibility at a real but bounded premium.
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to lease or buy a semi truck?
It depends on your mileage, cash position, and how long you intend to run the truck. Buying builds equity and is typically cheaper over the full ownership period once the loan is paid off. Leasing keeps monthly costs lower and lets you upgrade regularly, but you never own the asset and face per-mile penalties if you exceed the mileage cap. This calculator shows the break-even point — the month at which your cumulative net cost of buying (including equity build-up) drops below the cumulative lease cost.
What is a TRAC lease for commercial trucks?
A Terminal Rental Adjustment Clause (TRAC) lease is the most common commercial truck lease. At the end of the term you have the option to purchase the truck at a pre-set residual value, return it, or sell it. If the truck sells for more than the residual, you keep the difference; if it sells for less, you owe the shortfall. TRAC leases are treated as operating leases for tax purposes — the entire payment is deductible, not just interest and depreciation.
How do I estimate the residual value of my truck?
Heavy truck residual values depend heavily on brand, spec, mileage, and the freight market. A rule of thumb for a well-maintained Class 8 new truck: 40–50% of purchase price after 5 years at 500,000–600,000 cumulative miles. Used trucks depreciate faster. Check NADA Truck Guide or JM&A Commercial for current trade-in data. Enter a conservative number — overestimating the residual understates your true cost of ownership.
Can I write off both lease payments and loan interest as business expenses?
Yes, but differently. If you lease, the full monthly lease payment is a deductible operating expense. If you buy, you deduct loan interest (not principal) plus depreciation — Section 179 or bonus depreciation lets you expense most or all of the truck in year 1 if profitable enough. The tax advantage of ownership often tilts the math further toward buying for owner-operators in a profitable year.
What does the break-even month mean?
The break-even month is the point at which your cumulative net cost of ownership (all cash out minus equity you've built) equals your cumulative lease payments. Before that month, leasing has cost you less. After it, buying has cost you less. If the calculator shows no break-even within the analysis period, leasing is cheaper for the duration of the comparison window.